Sunday, January 19, 2014

Curling Science - Sweeping

I often ponder the physics of curling, and have previously posted on the drag effect here on the bayblab. These musings have yet to improve my game but as the winter olympics approach and as my beer league curling team suffers embarrassing defeats from inebriated senior citizens, I thought I would post some information I found on sweeping.

Sweeping is done by one or more players on the team whose rock is being shot. The players sweep the ice, using specific curling brooms, directly in the path of the travelling rock. Sweeping reduces the deceleration and the degree to which the path of the rock curls.
A common belief is that sweeping melts a thin layer of ice ahead of the rock and that the resulting thin layer of water decreases friction between the rock and the ice. An investigation into ice temperatures resulting from sweeping demonstrated that sweeping raised the ice temperature by 1.5C and achieved a maximum ice temperature of -1C. It was also found that raising the temperature of the ice was crucial for the effectiveness of sweeping but the temperature measurements, as determined by infrared camera, suggested that sweeping doesn't melt the ice. I do not understand the exact methodology or much about infrared cameras but I remain skeptical that a sufficiently thin layer of ice temperature can be measured in this way. It is known that the melting point of ice is decreased under pressure, such as the pressure experienced by ice under the weight of the rock. Therefore I don't know how conclusive it is that the effectiveness of sweeping is not due to contributing to the creation of a thin layer of lubricating water. Nonetheless, it is the momentarily increased ice temperature created by sweeping immediately ahead of the moving rock that makes it effective.
Not surprisingly, the mechanism by which sweeping increases the temperature of the ice is friction. The evolution of materials used for curling brooms reflects this fact, with the latest fabric broom heads enabling a dense contact surface area with the ice. The latest innovation in sweeping brooms is the incorporation of a heat reflective material behind the fabric broom head [link to patent (pdf)]. This reflects some of friction heat back towards the ice to increase the efficiency of sweeping.
None of the above information is going to help one's curling performance, however I did find a review that does have some practical applications for curlers. The first thing that I learned from this review is that it is actually against the rules to not sweep across the entire width of the contact point of the rock with the ice. 'Corner sweeping', as it is known, is when the rock is swept only on one side. By reducing the friction asymmetrically as the rock travels, the amount of curling can be influenced. While 'corner sweeping' is illegal, it is perfectly legal to sweep from either side of the rock. The review points out that more sweeping force is produced on the side closer to the sweeper. Therefore changing the side on which the rock is swept, or having the stronger sweeper on a particular side, might be advantageous for some shots.
Another big question is 'hurry or hard' when sweeping. The review finds that sweeping fast for fast moving rocks and hard for slow moving rocks produces the most friction heat beneath the moving rock. Sweeping fast for fast moving rocks makes sense as the speed of the rock may prevent multiple sweeping passes over the surface area under the rock. When the rock is moving slower it is easy to do multiple passes so it is best to push down hard when sweeping to maximize the heat produced by friction.
In reality none of this information is going to make me a better curler. However, at least the old boys I play with can't say that my poor performance is due to ignorance.


Blog27999 said...

You should see how my friend Wesley Virgin's report launches in this shocking and controversial video.

You see, Wesley was in the army-and shortly after leaving-he found hidden, "mind control" tactics that the CIA and others used to get whatever they want.

THESE are the exact same methods tons of famous people (notably those who "come out of nothing") and top business people used to become rich and famous.

You've heard that you only use 10% of your brain.

That's mostly because most of your BRAINPOWER is UNCONSCIOUS.

Maybe that thought has even occurred INSIDE your very own mind... as it did in my good friend Wesley Virgin's mind 7 years back, while riding a non-registered, trash bucket of a car without a driver's license and on his bank card.

"I'm so fed up with going through life paycheck to paycheck! When will I become successful?"

You've been a part of those those conversations, am I right?

Your very own success story is waiting to happen. All you need is to believe in YOURSELF.


Blog27999 said...

Look at the way my associate Wesley Virgin's autobiography launches with this shocking and controversial video.

Wesley was in the army-and shortly after leaving-he found hidden, "SELF MIND CONTROL" tactics that the government and others used to get everything they want.

As it turns out, these are the exact same secrets lots of celebrities (notably those who "became famous out of nowhere") and top business people used to become wealthy and famous.

You've heard that you utilize only 10% of your brain.

That's mostly because most of your BRAINPOWER is UNCONSCIOUS.

Perhaps that thought has even occurred INSIDE OF YOUR own brain... as it did in my good friend Wesley Virgin's brain around seven years ago, while riding an unlicensed, beat-up bucket of a car without a driver's license and $3 in his pocket.

"I'm very frustrated with going through life check to check! When will I become successful?"

You've taken part in those questions, ain't it so?

Your success story is going to start. All you have to do is in YOURSELF.

Watch Wesley Virgin's Video Now!

Unknown said...

Strange "water hack" burns 2 lbs in your sleep

Well over 160k men and women are losing weight with a easy and SECRET "water hack" to lose 2 lbs every night while they sleep.

It's easy and it works on everybody.

Here's how you can do it yourself:

1) Go grab a drinking glass and fill it up half glass

2) And now follow this amazing HACK

and become 2 lbs skinnier when you wake up!

Expert said...

Call Girls in Hyderabad We need genuine people looking Call Girls in Banjara Hills
and Vip single female locanto escorts service in Hyderabad Independent Escort Thank you very much for visiting Delhi NCR. Call Girls in Gurgaon

Split Ac Repair in Delhi NCR. Ac Repair Service in Rohini
Fridge, Window Ac, Split Ac Gas Filling service in Delhi All Electronic Machine Repair Samsung, Lg Ac Installation near me
AC Repair Service in Dwarka Delhi

Hitech City Call Girls AC Repair, Led tv repair best technician
lg Led tv repair service center near me LED TV Service Center in Delhi