Lumping all these things together as "alternative" is pretty misleading. Acupuncture is widely accepted enough to be used by a lot of endurance athletes (though the traditional claims for how it works probably aren't valid). Herbal medicine, practiced by someone who actually knows what they're doing, isn't that different from taking medication (where'd aspirin, opiates, penicillin, etc. come from, anyway?). Crystal healing, hmm, different story.
Matt has some interesting and good points. I'm sure this flowchart was written with comedic intent, but that doesn't mean it can't misinform people. It's largely unfair to dismiss these alternative healing methods right away just because they are not endorsed by pharmacists and doctors. Plus, that flowchart came from a self-proclaimed skeptic. I don't think skepticism proves anything wrong or right; it's mere opinion.
The bayblab is a collection of gradstudent post-graduate ramblings from labs all across the world in various states of employement.
Reviews of the podcast:
"The bayblab is so much better [than Science Friday]. It even has Stephen Hawking. All Ira Flatow can claim is that he’s interrupted people who are talking about Stephen Hawking."-Ben F.
"Penises, drugs, food and my music! What more could you ask for?"-KevinZ.
"Smart and snarky, the Bayblab team discuss science oddities, engaging in lively banter in the comments section that is an intellectual's playground." - Lim Leng Hiong
"Interesting news in science at slightly above the popscience level. Informal and funny."-Rumply
"When I happen to read a post, and it can be any post on this site, it is categorically thought inspiring"- Anders Rasmussen
"it's like butter melting over my pancakes good. I especially enjoyed the information on saving my genitals from a zipper accident."-Redge
2 comments:
Lumping all these things together as "alternative" is pretty misleading. Acupuncture is widely accepted enough to be used by a lot of endurance athletes (though the traditional claims for how it works probably aren't valid). Herbal medicine, practiced by someone who actually knows what they're doing, isn't that different from taking medication (where'd aspirin, opiates, penicillin, etc. come from, anyway?). Crystal healing, hmm, different story.
Matt has some interesting and good points. I'm sure this flowchart was written with comedic intent, but that doesn't mean it can't misinform people. It's largely unfair to dismiss these alternative healing methods right away just because they are not endorsed by pharmacists and doctors. Plus, that flowchart came from a self-proclaimed skeptic. I don't think skepticism proves anything wrong or right; it's mere opinion.
Post a Comment