Monday, December 15, 2014

Richard Dawkins debates homeopathy with Dr. Peter Fisher (2007)

Richard Dawkins made a television documentary called "The enemies of reason" in 2007. A large portion of the first part of the documentary is on homeopathy. You can watch it here. While I think it was a pretty good documentary that consisted of legitimate criticism, it was edited for television and was focused on "gotcha" moments. I think it also missed out on an educational opportunity to explain the rigorous methods of a well conducted randomized controlled trial. I recently ran across Dr. Peter Fisher's defence of NHS funding for homeopathy in the 'uncut' interview with Dawkins from the documentary.

This was probably the best defence of homeopathy I have ever seen. Despite this, with his usual style, Dawkins had Dr. Fisher on the ropes the entire time without even citing the evidence for a lack of homeopathic efficacy. Admittedly Dr. Fisher is an easy target, however I would hate to have to debate Dawkins on any subject. He finds common ground, concedes valid points, asks great questions, and lets his opponent talk him/herself into tight corners. From my biased perspective, in this interview Dawkins essentially had Dr. Fisher admit that homeopathy is a form of placebo. However, is there any context in which homeopathy could provide a safe, cost-effective treatment that is completely placebo? Probably not, however water is pretty cheap and safe.


5 comments:

Blog27999 said...

Your Affiliate Profit Machine is ready -

And making money online using it is as simple as 1, 2, 3!

Here is how it works...

STEP 1. Choose affiliate products you intend to promote
STEP 2. Add some PUSH BUTTON TRAFFIC (it LITERALLY takes JUST 2 minutes)
STEP 3. See how the system grow your list and sell your affiliate products all on it's own!

Do you want to start making profits???

The solution is right here

Pushkar Secret Fun said...

MAHABALESWAR CALL GIRL

PUSHKAR CALL GIRL HEENA

PUSHKAR CALL GIRL LIZA

PUSHKAR CALL GIRL NANDINI

VISAKHAPATNAM CALL GIRL

SURAT CALL GIRL

VADODARA CALL GIRL

VADODARA CALL GIRL NEHA

Payal Singh said...

The escorts in Mahipalpur are always stunning in every single young girl escort supplier and ceaselessly make a certain whole delight for their customers. The Mahipalpur escort girls are exceptionally very much talented and dependable. Mahipalpur Escorts| Dehradun Escorts | Delhi Escorts

Bed Pari Bangalore Escorts said...

Thanks for sharing this brilliant article it was a very useful and helpful article.

banaswadi escorts
koramangala escorts
mg road escorts
Jayanagar Escorts
VIP Escorts Bangalore
electronic city escorts

POOJA said...

If you have come to Hyderabad and you have a Call Girls in Banjara Hills
Call Girls in HiTech City very good business then you will have to spend a
lot of money and that is why you will feel very good in your life.